Movie Maker’s downfall

I put together a 15 minute compilation video in Windows Movie Maker. Now, WMM is okay… it’s free with XP and does the job of a basic movie editor quite well. Well, as long as you’re happy with it only spitting out WMV. Which I’m not overjoyed about.

WMM’s big problem is it doesn’t like MPEGs. Oh sure, it’ll work with them, but it doesn’t like them. I can’t find any other explanation for how slow it gets when dealing with them. Once you have a few MPEGs in your project, you’ll find it takes an agonisingly long time to re-open the project. Seriously, by the time I got finished I had 15 minute long project with a couple of dozen MPEG-1 clips, and it literally took two hours of “checking project files” before I could do anything.

I thought it was some kind of hideous mistake the first time it happened, and cancelled and rebooted the machine. But it wasn’t. I ended up doing some research (on another PC, since that one was busy burning up CPU and disk cycles) and the word on the forums is that it just doesn’t like MPEGs. Throw a bunch of AVI or WMV videos at it, and it’s fine.

Well, I say fine, but in fact WMM regularly freezes up. My kids describe it as “going out to lunch” and it’s a source of constant frustration.

As it happens I’ve just bought Pinnacle Studio Plus version 10 ($189 via Harris Technology, and widely available elsewhere), something of an upgrade from both WMM and the Pinnacle Studio Quickstart 9 I got with the TV tuner card I just bought. Australian purchases of Studio Plus (and a couple of other Pinnacle products) will get a bonus USB TV tuner if they buy before the end of the year. (Yes, this is a bummer for me. Maybe I’ll put one of them on eBay.) So hopefully the next video project won’t be subject to WMM’s vagaries.

Other lessons: Google Video suggests 640 x 480 is the ideal resolution for uploads. But this resulted in a file close to 100Mb long, which not only took ages to upload, but was also sluggish on playback. Eventually I downsized it to 320×240, and it’s much faster in both cases, though quite pixellated. The default Google player (embedded in a web page) is actually 400×300, though I’m not sure this is actually supported in an AVI or WMV file, since Tmpgenc refused to resize to that, saying that 300 isn’t divisible by 16.

More on Studio Plus when I actually get around to installing and using it.

If you enjoyed this post, please consider leaving a comment or subscribing to the RSS feed to have future articles delivered to your feed reader.

3 thoughts on “Movie Maker’s downfall

  1. celina

    i must say windows movie maker sucks when it comes to compatibility with video files.
    i made a 40 minute project with a lot of avi files and a couple jpegs and mp3s. for one thing, it won’t save itself as a movie file. so i had to cut the project into 4 parts.
    another thing’s that, when i re-open the 40 minute project (which i am currently doing right now), it’s taking like 2 hours so far, AND IM NOT EVEN HALFWAY! bummer huh? so yeah. this is my geeky rant. i would never use wmm anymore. :[

  2. HANK

    No shit…this waiting for the avi’s,mpg’s and mpeg’s is for elementary school students that have nothing else better to
    do than wait for the green dots to fill up the line and open sesame’! My green dots are full and all I can do is sit…
    It really screws up my train of thought and momentum.

  3. MenTaL

    I get the problem of taking ages to open project file even if there are only AVI files in it. WMM takes too long even to import video files into collections. What does it do actually? It looks like it is converting all those avi files to some other format and degrading its quality.

Comments are closed.